Mon 18 Feb 2008
The effects of old narratives
Posted by Misha under Culture
In the focus group I did with HIV+ people on Sunday, someone raised a really interesting point. There used to be all sorts of movies about AIDS, all with the same inevitable theme — death. Someone gets AIDS, and they have to set their affairs in order, or reunite with their family, or even sue for their rights, as in Philadelphia. I loved Tom Hanks in that movie, but he still died in the end.
Nowadays, with antiretrovirals, there’s not as obvious a dramatic arc. Tom Hanks gets HIV, goes on ARVs, and lives happily ever after in that loft with Antonio Banderas. That’s not a story! So stories about people living with HIV are just a lot less common these days, outside of some gay-oriented media that doesn’t always make it overseas. (Given the importance that Christianity and Zulu traditional spirituality, both extremely conservative, play in the lives of the people I’ve met here, I can’t imagine Queer As Folk going over big in Kwa-Zulu Natal.)
However, that doesn’t mean that all those “HIV and then death” stories aren’t still out there — movies, especially, have a long afterlife. And so the belief that AIDS is always already a death sentence persists and is reinforced. The question then becomes: how do you tell a mainstream story in which someone’s survival on ARV isn’t miraculous or presented as a great triumph, but just the ordinary order of things?

February 18th, 2008 at 1:34 pm
I would say that the horror of being doomed to live with Antonio Banderas has plenty of drama to offer . . .
And since I’ve already alienated all the Banderas lovers out there, I offer up the revelation that yes, I do watch General Hospital, which has a core character who contracted HIV during the course of the show and has been living with it for more than 10 years. Currently, she’s dealing with the issues of being HIV+ and pregnant. But the issues of conservatism certainly still stand.
February 19th, 2008 at 9:48 am
Hey! This was the pre-Melanie Antonio! He was hot.
And good to know about GH — I need all the data points I can get.